This article of phpBB and vBulletin comparison I wrote in 2009 when I really recommended vBulletin but that is not the case anymore. The progress of vBulletin since vBulletin 4 and 5 is so disappointing that finally I had to give up on vBulletin. I have shared why I have given up on vBulletin as well as what next here.
I get lots of queries from many phpBB webmasters asking "why vBulletin" when we have phpBB which is free with same features as vBulletin. I will try to answer this question here for all. Remember that vBulletin has countless more features than phpBB.
The main thing I like about vBulletin is - I know it well and I am familiar with it. That was not the case when I started with vBulletin but I choose vBulletin over phpBB over and over again because
- phpBB back in 2004 when I tried on my localhost had the issue of logging into the admin panel. Logging in twice was not well understood by me. I am not sure if this is still there or not but that was first bad impression.
- phpBB Hacks are very much dependent on the theme you use and normally the free plugins we get are mainly for the default theme which is very unlikely we would be using it and so for each plugin you decide to use, you would need it to work for your theme can be a tough ask.
- vBulletin always try to get the new plugins integrated into the product as features. When I started with vBulletin 3.0 it was pretty much elementary but now we see many plugins as an integrated part of the product.
- vBulletin integrated Adsense which means if you want to have Adsense Ads on your forum all you need to do is Add Adsense publisher id into your vBulletin member area and done. I mentioned this feature specially because when I work for clients in Elance, they are non-technical people and love this feature a lot.
- Making plugins integrated with the original products makes it more secure because at times plugins could be prone to security holes as well as performance degradation. phpBB website was once down for some plugin had security flaw.
- When any security flaw is detected in any vBulletin release they patch it very fast and normally in less than 24 hours.
- Comprehensive documentation so that it helps me develop my own plugins very easily but when it comes to phpBB I do not see as good documentation as vBulletin.
- Apart from the vBulletin SEOed we have a very good SEO product called vbSEO but the one for phpBB did not impress me.
- vBulletin 4 is underway now which would take lots of features from vbSEO features of vBulletin.
- vBulletin Administration is much easier to manage than Invision or phpBB. Check out the Admin Demo yourself as well.
- If you already have a phpBB community there is an option for Impex to move your phpBB forum into vBulletin and it works like some clicks and all done.
- vBulletin has lots more features than phpBB like Notices, Template Hooks, Similar threads and many more which I like a lot.
- vBulletin has much cleaner code and so creating new plugins become easier.
- I am using vBulletin Blog on my MBA Forum which is quite good as well.
Currently I have 6 vBulletin licenses (many coming up) which does speak for itself because being a tech guy if I could have managed with phpBB I would have done that.